By allowing for various possible interpretations, the EU Commission manages to sidestep any outward criticism to Israel, while defending a principled stand on humanitarian commitments.
Nikolaj Nielsen
The European Commission has consistently advised against maritime aid missions to Palestinians in Gaza — citing significant safety risks.
That warning was reiterated earlier this week, after Israeli forces intercepted the Global Sumud Flotilla off the coast of Crete, detaining activists and seizing the vessels.
But is the commission referring to inherit risks of long-distance sailing, or is it a warning of possible brutal Israeli tactics — or both?
When pressed to explain these risks, the commission has avoided singling out Israeli tactics, instead calling on Israel to comply with international and maritime law.
By allowing for various possible interpretations, the commission manages to sidestep any outward criticism of Israel, while defending a principled stand on humanitarian commitments.
But it is precisely this diplomatic ambiguity that fails to challenge Israeli naval interceptions, undermining Brussels’ stated commitment humanitarian operations.
This also includes conveniently deferring to EU member state authorities whenever one of its nationals are detained or arrested by Israelis.
Both Saif Abukeshek, a Spanish-Swedish national of Palestinian origin and Brazilian Thiago Avila were taken from the flotilla of 22 boats and detained in Israel, amid claims they have ties to Hamas.
“When it comes to consular protection, as you know, it is ensured by EU member states,” said the commission, when asked about Abukeshek’s fate.
Jose Manuel Albares, Spain’s ministry of foreign affairs, has since stepped in and demanded Israel release Abukeshek.
“Israel has not put on the table any evidence about Abukeshek’s relationship with Hamas,” said Albares.
A court in Israel has since extended the detention of Abukeshek and Avila.
